Rentier peace or resource curse? The ambiguous effects of oil wealth and oil dependency on violent conflict
نویسنده
چکیده
The 'paradox of plenty' and the 'resource curse' hypotheses claim that abundance in natural resources, particularly oil, encourages civil war through a number of causal mechanisms. Natural resources provide both motive and opportunity for conflict, rent seeking slows down growth and renders state institutions weak thus creating indirect causes of violent conflict. Contrarily, the theory of the rentier state – largely neglected in the study of peace and war in this respect – suggests that regimes use revenue from abundant resources to buy off peace through corruption, large-scale distributive policies and effective repression. Consequently, such rentier states would tend to be more stable politically and less prone to conflict. These two theories thus imply ambivalent effects of resource abundance on political stability and conflict proneness. This paper presents part of a solution to this apparent puzzle for the case of oil-producing countries. The key argument is that resource wealth per capita needs to be taken into account, since only the availability of very high per capita revenues from oil allows governments to achieve internal stability. Our empirical analyses confirm this hypothesis. More specifically, multivariate crosscountry regressions based on replication datasets show an inverted-U-shaped relationship between revenues from oil per capita and violent conflict. We detect the opposite linkage (U-shape) for the effect of oil dependence measured in terms of oil exports as share of GDP. The politically stabilizing effect of resource wealth is also demonstrated in a macro-qualitative comparison for a reduced sample of highly dependent oil exporters. Using the same reduced sample, the paper also examines whether the mechanisms hypothesized by the rentier state theory are at work. Our findings suggest that oil wealthy countries manage to maintain stability by a combination of large-scale distribution, high spending on the security apparatus, and protection by outsiders. In contradiction to the rentier state theory, the institutions of these wealthy countries do not seem to be characterised by patronage and clientelism.
منابع مشابه
Avoiding Turmoil: A Comparative Exploration of the ‘Resource Curse’
As petroleum extraction and consumption has steadily increased in recent decades, economists and development researchers have been puzzled by discrepancies in the growth, development, and governance of oil-dependent countries around the world. The divergent development outcomes of oil states beg the following question: what are the political and economic conditions that determine the consequenc...
متن کاملDutch Disease, Rentier State, and Resource Curse: A Characteristic Triangle and Ultra Challenge in the Iranian Economy
O wning Natural resources has been beneficial for some Countries, but hurtful for some others. Optimum management of natural resources in the former group has enhanced economic growth, bad governance, however, has led to Dutch Disease in the latter group. Bad governance in Iran has created Dutch Disease, Rentier State, and Resource Curse, DRR as a characteristic triangle. As the Iran...
متن کاملNatural Resources, Institutions Quality, and Economic Growth; A Cross-Country Analysis
Abstract[1] Natural resources as a source of wealth can increase prosperity or impede economic growth. Empirical studies with different specifications and data are also mixed on whether natural resources are curse or blessing. In fact, the variety of model specifications, measurements, and samples in the empirical literature makes it difficult to generalize the results. In this study, a growth...
متن کاملThe crazy curse and crude domination: Toward an anthropology of oil
Oil has turned out to be something of a curse. Most developing petrostates have found that their economies have worsened, their political regimes have become more authoritarian, and their conflicts have intensified. Further, this curse is a bit crazy because oil brings wealth, which would seem to bring peace and prosperity, not the trouble that so often accompanies it. The goal of this introduc...
متن کاملInstitutional Quality and Curse Resources: An Experimental Study on OPEC Countries
This paper is to study the resource curse applying annual data from 2002 to 2016 for the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) members i.e. Algeria, Iran, Kuwait, Nigeria, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, United Arab Emirates and Venezuela. For this purpose, there were concerned the interactions role of resource abundance and institution quality, and their marginal effect of the countrie...
متن کامل